In some circles, the events surrounding the Stanford prison experiment were a reflection of heroism while in others the issues of ethics were cited as a pointer to the unacceptable nature of the participating subjects. Specifically, Maslach was seen as a hero for stopping the experiments (Haney, Banks & Zimbardo, 1973).
Palo Alto Police arrested nine young men on August, 1971. Apparently, the arresting was being captured by cameras. The hand cuffing exercise was broadcast by newsrooms. The arrested men were among roughly seventy people who were willing to participate in the experiment for a paltry fifteen dollars a day. Worse still, the Palo Alto Times contributed by publicizing the experiment. After some psychological tests and interviews, two dozens of the participants, deemed to be most appropriate for the exercise, were chosen and assigned to be either prisoners or guards. Those who were assigned prison status were booked into real jails before being blindfolded before being driven into a makeshift prison at Jordan Hall. Those assigned the role of guards were handed uniforms and given instructions not to use violence. However, they were to control the prisons.
Buy Free Custom «The Stanford Prison Experiment» Essay Paper paper online
Based on the views of the researchers, the experiment assumed an interesting twist in day two when the prisoners revolted. After successfully crushing the rebellion, the guards increased their levels of aggression against the prisoners. Similarly, they began humiliating and dehumanizing the prisoners. Nevertheless, the researchers kept reminding the guards to control their aggression. However, this did not work as the guards often forced the prisoners to wash the toilet bowels using their bare hands. The rising levels of mistreatment forced the researchers to release five overstressed prisoners prematurely.
The research had the objective of focusing on power rules, roles, symbols, situational validation of behavior, and group identity. To achieve the goal, engaging in acts of deindividuation and dehumanizing was necessary. This leads to posing questions on what I could have done if I were a guard or prisoner.
The guards could take prisoners having their heads covered by paper bags on their way to the bathrooms. In short, the guards were mistreating the prisoners. If I were a guard in this experiment, I could have attempted to adhere to my ethical orientations which entail respecting human life. However, the fact that I have been recruited for a fee to participate could have undermined my chances of being observant of ethical demands. Hence, I could have ended doing the same aspects as the other guards. In regards to being a prisoner, my position remains the same. As a recruited person, there is a challenge to force your views. However, I could not withstand such kind of mistreatment. Hence, I could have withdrawn from the experiment.
The issue of ethics has for a long time dominated the scientific discourse. Ethics regarding the recruitment of the young people for the experiment refuse to go away. Similarly, the ethics of dehumanizing fellow human beings pose a serious challenge.
In the experiment, the researchers made the subjects believe that they were helpful in delivering electric shocks to the strangers. The exercise had severe effects on the subject which they were not informed about. Similarly, the public exposure of subjects was unethical since the information leaked was personal. Furthermore, the act of informing some subjects that they failed was unacceptable given the demoralizing effect such a move would have.
Despite the ethical issues raised, the idea that the experiment followed the guidelines set by the Stanford Human Subjects Ethics Committee would absolve the researchers from any wrongdoing. Hence, relying on this realization, it could be assumed that the experiment was ethical. However, the mistreatment of the subjects is indefensible. Consequently, it was unethical.
The study could not pass the scientific tenets such as the principle of replicability. For an ethical scientific approach, replicability is necessary. However, it is not possible in this exercise. From this point, the issue of generalizability also emerges. The sample was not representative since only volunteers were picked.
FREE Extras:
- FREE revision (within 2 days)
- FREE title page
- FREE bibliography
- FREE outline (on request)
- FREE e-mail delivery
- FREE formatting
We Guarantee:
- Quality research and writing
- 24/7/365 Live support
- MA, BA, and PhD degree writers
- 100% Confidentiality
- No hidden charges
- Never resold works
- Complete authenticity
Paper Format:
- 12 pt. Times New Roman
- Double-spaced/Single-spaced papers
- 1 inch margins
- Any citation style
- Up-to-date sources only
- Fully referenced papers
Related Sociology essays
0
Preparing Orders
0
Active Writers
0%
Positive Feedback
0
Support Agents
Dissertation chapter - Literature ..., 4 pages
This writer is perfection at its best. She reads and follows the instructions and completes assignments promptly to assist you in completing the assignment on time. So happy I found this writer. She is 5-star plus!!
John R., USA
9:32 AM, Feb 17, 2025
Blog Article, 4 pages
great paper as usual
Kristen P., USA
7:42 AM, Feb 17, 2025
Literature Review, 9 pages
1 paragraph short of 2 pages
Gea E., USA
7:22 AM, Feb 17, 2025
Revision, 14 pages
it was a amazing essay thx so much
Bhupendra A., Australia
6:49 AM, Feb 17, 2025
Dissertation chapter - Hypothesis, 11 pages
This's a good writer done my work in before the due time, which gave time to read and no stress.
Viet P., USA
8:42 PM, Feb 13, 2025
Research proposal, 5 pages
Great paper and got it before due date!
Hieu P., USA
11:09 PM, Feb 17, 2025
Literature Review, 8 pages
Better than the last, but again offline and could not do a revision. I did it myself. Attention to details is an effective part of writing, just saying.
Jannette V., USA
9:01 PM, Feb 17, 2025
Poem, 9 pages
Recieved paper early and had great knowledge!
Avetis K., Indonesia
6:36 PM, Feb 17, 2025
Discussion Board Post, 15 pages
good writer and did meet the timeline
Lisa G., USA
3:36 PM, Feb 17, 2025
Marketing Plan, 18 pages
perfect, but reply too slow
Jonathan R., Japan
3:13 PM, Feb 17, 2025
Dissertation chapter - Literature ..., 4 pages
This writer is perfection at its best. She reads and follows the instructions and completes assignments promptly to assist you in completing the assignment on time. So happy I found this writer. She is 5-star plus!!
John R., USA
9:32 AM, Feb 17, 2025
Blog Article, 4 pages
great paper as usual
Kristen P., USA
7:42 AM, Feb 17, 2025
Literature Review, 9 pages
1 paragraph short of 2 pages
Gea E., USA
7:22 AM, Feb 17, 2025
Revision, 14 pages
it was a amazing essay thx so much
Bhupendra A., Australia
6:49 AM, Feb 17, 2025
Dissertation chapter - Hypothesis, 11 pages
This's a good writer done my work in before the due time, which gave time to read and no stress.
Viet P., USA
8:42 PM, Feb 13, 2025
Research proposal, 5 pages
Great paper and got it before due date!
Hieu P., USA
11:09 PM, Feb 17, 2025
Literature Review, 8 pages
Better than the last, but again offline and could not do a revision. I did it myself. Attention to details is an effective part of writing, just saying.
Jannette V., USA
9:01 PM, Feb 17, 2025
Poem, 9 pages
Recieved paper early and had great knowledge!
Avetis K., Indonesia
6:36 PM, Feb 17, 2025
Discussion Board Post, 15 pages
good writer and did meet the timeline
Lisa G., USA
3:36 PM, Feb 17, 2025
Marketing Plan, 18 pages
perfect, but reply too slow
Jonathan R., Japan
3:13 PM, Feb 17, 2025