Sales: Sales: Support: Support:
Academic writing services  
Custom written essay Book report Research paper Dissertation Resume and CV Editing and proofreading  
main menu
By ordering custom paper you get
  • 24/7 Support
  • Over 100 professional US Writers
  • 300 words per page
  • Flexible discount system
  • FREE revision (within 2 days)
  • Anti-Plagiarism Software Check
we accept
sample essays
Accounting Essays
Admission Essays
Analysis Essays
Art Essays
Biography Essays
Biology Essays
Book Review Essays
Business Essays
Case Studies Essays
Cause and Effect Essays
Character Analysis Essays
Communication Essays
Communication and Media Essays
Compute Technologies Essays
Consideration Essays
Controversial Essays
Description Essays
Economics Essays
Education Essays
Evaluation Essays
Explanation Essays
History Essays
Job Essays
Law Essays
Management Essays
Medicine Essays
Music Essays
Personal Essays
Personal Experience Essays
Persuasive Essays
Persuasive Speech Essays
Philosophy Essays
Political science Essays
Politics Essays
Proposal Essays
Psychology Essays
Reflective Essays
Religion Essays
Research Essays
Response Essays
School Essays
Science Essays
Sociology Essays
Technology Essays
World Literature Essays
What Makes a Good Poem? essay
← Sleep and Dreams as Central Themes in A Midsummer Night’s DreamBlink →

What Makes a Good Poem?. Custom What Makes a Good Poem? Essay Writing Service || What Makes a Good Poem? Essay samples, help

The definition of a ‘good poem’, as well as of the poet’s role and qualities in general, varies among the different commentators. In this short essay, the opinions by James Tate, Robert Bly, Billy Collins, and Matthew Dickman on the constituent features of a ‘good poem’ and its evaluation criteria shall be examined. However, its main aim shall be to present my own view on the subject matter, being based on the propositions derived from the aforementioned authors.

In Tate’s opinion, the definition of a ‘good poem’ proceeding from certain objective criteria is scarcely possible, as the poets do not necessarily craft their works under the impact of some personal experience or the external situations. Nor is poetry a simple expression of social and cultural life; as noted by Tate, the readers “don’t just want to have [their] ideas or emotions confirmed” (18). On the contrary, poetry is “a search for the unknown”, and each individual poem may arise spontaneously as the result of the poet’s internal and supra-rational need to uncover some new horizons in human language and expressive abilities. Moreover, the real poetry does not rest upon the exact words it contains; it is the interpretation, the “unspoken [that] rests in the darkness” (Tate 19) that may embody the real spirit and appeal of poetry.

For Bly, a good poetry is predicated upon the notion of “dragon smoke” (161), i.e. an equally supra-rational ability to freely form one’s associative vocabulary and to transition from one (conscious) state of self-expression to another (unconscious). In Bly’s opinion, while in pre-Christian era, a poet would be free to carry out such a ‘leap’, the Christian and post-Christian capitalist society have repressed this creative streak in favor of a linear and rational-reductive reasoning, thus contributing to the gradual withering away of the poetry’s associative richness (Bly 163). Thus, a good poem would be the attempt at replicating this lost world of wild artistic creativity exemplified by a ‘leap’ notion.

On the other hand, for Collins, poetry is the most rational activity of all possible. In his interpretation, a poet, just as his/her reader, attempts to “create a logical, rational path through the day”, and, in spite of each and any obstacle, the poet is willing to stop at any place and in any time frame (“Billy Collins”). Thus, a good poem would be then that addresses its reader’s concern and enables the latter to understand the rationale of a poet’s argument. This rationalist argument appears to be in a stark contrast with the other noted poets’ viewpoints, representing a more ‘commonsense’ understanding of the poet’s role.

Still, Dickman clings to the inspirationalist view of the poetry’s sources and occurrences. Judging from Dickman’s interview (“Matthew Dickman”), he seems to be a believer in the instantaneous and supra-rational nature of poetry, as he claims that “I believe the whole poem was “received” only some of that reception came through pulling my hair out and chewing the end of a pen to death. Every poem is “received.” (“Matthew Dickman”). Hence, the majority of the aforementioned poets appear to regard poetry as the activity that cannot be rationally conceived or construed.

In view of these arguments, I may claim that a good poem is the piece of poetry that combines two key factors: 1. a rich associative and interpretational vocabulary (including the generation of new meanings) and 2. a potential to reach out to the potential audience so as to address their strivings for the qualitatively new meaning. Hence, the evaluation of such a poem would encompass both the poet’s intrinsic ability to craft new works of literature and the extrinsic capacity of his/her readership to integrate the poet’s insights. In this way, a multi-dimensional understanding of professional poetry may be attained.

What Makes a Good Poem?. Custom What Makes a Good Poem? Essay Writing Service || What Makes a Good Poem? Essay samples, help

Order Now
Order nowhesitating

Related essays

  1. Blink
  2. We Become What We Behold
  3. Sleep and Dreams as Central Themes in A Midsummer Night’s Dream
  4. That Only a Mother: Literal Analysis

order now

Order now
why choose us
96% of satisfied returning customers
24/7 customer support
A wide range of services
Up-to-date sources
100% privacy guaranteed
MA/PhD writers
Custom written papers only
Free plagiarism report
Free revision (within 2 days)
Free extras by your request
Direct communication with a writer
Are your writers qualified for the custom writing?
How quick can my order be accomplished?
Is it legal to buy custom essays, term papers or book reports from your company?
Are essays offered by your company truly custom-written?
Is it safe to buy from
How secure is the payment system of your company?
Can I submit custom essays or term papers done by your company as my own?
How can I contact your company if I've got problems with my ordered paper?

Finally, I've found the real custom writing service . My grades are saying "Thank you, it's been a pleasure to work with you."

Jamal, South Africa

I can't believe you finished my essay under such a short deadline! You saved me from a disaster once again. You guys deliver exactly what you promise. I'll be back. That's for sure!

William H , Kansas, US

contact us
Toll free for US & Canada only. International callers are charged for outgoing calls.

Our phone numbers: provides custom term paper writing/rewriting services inclusive of research material for assistance purposes only. The term papers should be used with proper reference and are not meant to replace actual assignments.

Get 15% off your first custom essay order

Order now

from $12.99/PAGE